That "mess" included a large part of the 2006 national championship team. I would hardly say that Meyer had a big mess to clean up, if any mess at all. Zook was put into a no-win situation and he did the best he could. Yes, he could have been better, but Zook certainly wasn't this failure that he is made out to be.
And unlike Meyer, SOS didn't "overcome" 3 years of a poor coach who at least was a good recruiter that left the cupboard with good players. SOS not only overcame 80 YEARS of mediocrity, he overcame UF being on probation. He was the first Gator coach to have sustained success over a long period of time. THAT is why he is put on a pedestal. I really don't understand how some Gator fans can't appreciate how enormous an impact Spurrier had at UF.
I must agree to disagree again. Zook was hardly put into a "no-win" situation"'; he made the same mistakes over and over again that cost us wins or almost cost us wins. Zook may have been able to recruit, but he did leave some positions on the depth chart thin that Meyer was forced to compensate for with having to move players to different positions. Zook was a poor clock manager, couldn't effectively solve problems, and was a weak gameday strategist who, more often than not, played to avoid a loss instead of going all out for the win. There was no excuse for losing the 2003 Outback Bowl to Michigan (that "Rex was open" stunt was idiocy on Zook's part), NOR any excuse for his having coughed up a decent lead in that 2003 game against Miami. Add the embarassment he caused UF as a whole - not to mention himself - over "Fratgate", and that made him look even more ridiculous. Zook had every opportunity to succeed when the odds were stacked against him, and he couldn't do it. "Players-only" meetings that were called during the Zook years were an indication that the leadership coming from the coaching staff was either weak, inadequate, or a combination of both. In the end, the Zook firing was necessary to avoid further deterioration of our football program. Enough was enough.
What Meyer was forced to overcome when he assumed control of the program was low morale, weak leadership, players who were not as conditioned as they should have been to play 60 solid minutes of football, poor academic performance and, in general, a locker room with no real sense of order. It so happens that I watched an "Under the Lights" segment on Meyer several times on Sun Sports, and one thing that stands out is a remark he made to Eric Wilbur back in 2005 that "we have too many soft people on this team". Indeed, Meyer had issues to deal with that he inherited from Zook.
I'm not denying the fact that SOS turned UF football around after probation, but he's not perfect, either. Too many fans think he can do no wrong, and I refuse to be one of them. Like I said, I respect what he accomplished as a coach, but I do have an issue with his personality.