• Welcome to Green Bay Packers NFL Football Forum & Community!
    Packer Forum is one of the largest online communities for the Green Bay Packers.

    You are currently viewing our community forums as a guest user.

    Sign Up or

    Having an account grants you additional privileges, such as creating and participating in discussions. Furthermore, we hide most of the ads once you register as a member! Furthermore, we hide most of the ads once you register as a member!

The Next Coach of the Florida Gators will be...

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
Betting sites are already posting odds for the next Gator coach in 2025. The ones that I consider realistic will be highlighted in orange for discussion later in the thread. Blue indicates interesting guesses that others have been highlighting on social media. The ones in red are not realistic despite the higher betting odds, at least in my opinion. The names in gray are lower odds, but should be watched in case the betting line moves up.
  • Jamey Chadwell (+400) 5/1
  • Lane Kiffin (+500) 6/1
  • Deion Sanders (+600) 7/1
  • Eli Drinkwitz (+700) 8/1
  • Brent Key (+800) 9/1
  • Brian Schottenheimer (+900) 10/1
  • Glenn Schumann 12/1
  • Chris Klieman 12/1
  • Matt Rhule 14/1
  • Josh Heupel 14/1
  • Brent Venables 18/1
  • Lance Leipold 18/1
  • Mark Stoops 25/1
  • Shane Beamer 25/1
  • Jeff Brohm 25/1
  • Alex Golesh 25/1
  • Mario Cristobal 33/1
  • Mack Brown 33/1
  • Dave Doeren 33/1
  • Teryl Austin 33/1
  • Gus Malzahn 33/1
  • PJ Fleck also 33/1
  • Dan Lanning 40/1
  • B-Kelly 40/1
  • Jedd Fisch 50/1
  • Ryan Day 50/1
  • Oscar Liar 66/1
  • Mike Gundy 66/1
  • Kalen DeBoer 75/1
  • Kirby Smart 100/1
  • Dan Mullen 100/1
  • Mike Norvell 100/1
  • Dan Quinn 100/1
  • Muschamp 100/1
  • Nick Saban 100/1
  • Jim Harbaugh 100/1
  • Tim Tebow 150/1
  • Danny Wuerffel 200/1
  • Jesse Palmer 200/1
  • Steve Spurrier 250/1
  • Emmitt Smith 300/1
  • Cris Collinsworth 300/1
 
Last edited:

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
Jamey Chadwell has been the head coach at Liberty since 2023, where he has a 16-1 record. His overall coaching record is 114-58 with stints at North Greenville (2009-2011), Delta State (2012), and Coastal Carolina (2017, 2019-2022). He has won conference championships in Conference USA (2023), Sun Belt (2020), and Big South (2015 - vacated by NCAA, 2016). Chadwell's resume looks a lot like Billy Napier's, so I am a bit hesitant to pick him as the next head coach.
 

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
Lane Kiffin apparently is the favorite on social media. Kiffin has been head coach of the Ole Miss Rebels since 2020, where he has a 37-15 record. His overall record is 97-49 in college, 5-15 in the NFL. He has two Conference USA championships (2017, 2019). There has been discussion on his run-ins with Florida and the SEC stemming from an incident in 2009 when he accused Urban Meyer of violating NCAA recruiting rules while at a public speaking engagement at the Knoxville Convention Center. Lane does have some loose ties to Florida as the ex-husband of Layla Reaves Kiffin, daughter of Gator Great John Reaves. His son, Knox Kiffin, is an unrated, 6'0" 170-pound 2028 QB out of Palos Verdes Peninsula, CA.

 

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
Here is a list of coaches with championships and time in a power conference. Chris Klieman is the only coach on the betting odds list above with a championship.
CoachChampionshipsYears Power ConfWL%
Urban Meyer
2006, 2008 BCS Champion, 2014 CFP Champion​
13​
86.1
Chris Klieman​
2022 Big 12 Champion​
6​
63.6
Pat Narduzzi​
2021 ACC Champion​
10​
57.6
Luke Fickell​
2021 CFP Participant​
3​
51.7
Jimbo Fisher
2013 BCS Champion​
14​
72.7
Gus Malzahn​
2013 BCS Runner-Up​
10​
65.6
Chip Kelly​
2010 BCS Runner-Up​
10​
66.4
Mike Gundy​
2011 Big 12 Champion​
20​
68.2
Kyle Whittingham​
2021, 2022 Pac-12 Champion​
14​
64.5
Mario Cristobal​
2019, 2020 Pac-12 Champion​
8​
65.8
Clay Helton​
2017 Pac-12 Champion​
7​
65.7
Gene Chizik
2010 BCS Champion​
6​
50.0
Sonny Dykes​
2022 CFP Participant​
7​
49.4
Brian Kelly​
2012 BCS Runner-Up​
15​
73.8
Mack Brown
2005 BCS Champion​
32​
68.9
Kalen DeBoer​
2023 CFP Runner-Up​
3​
90.3
Steve Sarkisian​
2023 CFP Participant​
10​
59.2
Kirby Smart
2021, 2022 CFP Champion​
9​
85.8
Ryan Day​
2020 CFP Runner-Up​
6​
87.3
Lincoln Riley​
2017, 2018, 2019 CFP Participant​
8​
80.9
Dabo Swinney
2016, 2018 CFP Champion​
17​
79.5
Gary Patterson​
2014 Big 12 Champion​
10​
59.5
James Franklin​
2016 Big 10 Champion​
14​
67.9
Bret Bielema​
2010, 2011, 2012 Big 10 Champion​
16​
60.5
Kirk Firentz​
2002, 2004 Big 10 Champion​
26​
62.3
Jim Harbaugh​
2023 CFP Champion​
13​
71.7
Pete Carroll
2003, 2004 BCS Champion, 2013 Super Bowl Champion​
9​
83.6
Mark Helfrich​
2014 CFP Runner-Up​
4​
69.8
Ed Orgeron
2019 CFP Champion​
10​
58.8
Les Miles​
2007 BCS Champion​
18​
66.5
Mike Norvell​
2023 ACC Champion​
5​
60.8
Dave Aranda​
2021 Big 12 Champion​
5​
49.0
Art Briles​
2013, 2014 Big 12 Champion​
8​
63.7

Now that college football looks somewhat like the NFL, it is easier to compare NFL resumes and apply them to college. Some of these former coaches could be good General Managers at the collegiate level if they are too old to coach.
CoachChampionshipsYears Coaching NFLWL%
Bill Belichik6X Super Bowl Champion2468.7
Mike Shanahan2X Super Bowl Champion2055.2
Jon GrudenSuper Bowl XXXVII Champion1551.1
 
Last edited:

DRU2012

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Betting sites are already posting odds for the next Gator coach in 2025. The ones that I consider realistic will be highlighted in orange for discussion later in the thread. Blue indicates interesting guesses that others have been highlighting on social media. The ones in red are not realistic despite the higher betting odds, at least in my opinion. The names in gray are lower odds, but should be watched in case the betting line moves up.
  • Jamey Chadwell (+400) 5/1
  • Lane Kiffin (+500) 6/1
  • Deion Sanders (+600) 7/1
  • Eli Drinkwitz (+700) 8/1
  • Brent Key (+800) 9/1
  • Brian Schottenheimer (+900) 10/1
  • Glenn Schumann 12/1
  • Chris Klieman 12/1
  • Matt Rhule 14/1
  • Josh Heupel 14/1
  • Brent Venables 18/1
  • Lance Leipold 18/1
  • Mark Stoops 25/1
  • Shane Beamer 25/1
  • Jeff Brohm 25/1
  • Alex Golesh 25/1
  • Mario Cristobal 33/1
  • Mack Brown 33/1
  • Dave Doeren 33/1
  • Teryl Austin 33/1
  • Gus Malzahn 33/1
  • PJ Fleck also 33/1
  • Dan Lanning 40/1
  • B-Kelly 40/1
  • Jedd Fisch 50/1
  • Ryan Day 50/1
  • Oscar Liar 66/1
  • Mike Gundy 66/1
  • Kalen DeBoer 75/1
  • Kirby Smart 100/1
  • Dan Mullen 100/1
  • Mike Norvell 100/1
  • Dan Quinn 100/1
  • Muschamp 100/1
  • Nick Saban 100/1
  • Jim Harbaugh 100/1
  • Tim Tebow 150/1
  • Danny Wuerffel 200/1
  • Jesse Palmer 200/1
  • Steve Spurrier 250/1
  • Emmitt Smith 300/1
  • Cris Collinsworth 300/1
Jamey Chadwell has been the head coach at Liberty since 2023, where he has a 16-1 record. His overall coaching record is 114-58 with stints at North Greenville (2009-2011), Delta State (2012), and Coastal Carolina (2017, 2019-2022). He has won conference championships in Conference USA (2023), Sun Belt (2020), and Big South (2015 - vacated by NCAA, 2016). Chadwell's resume looks a lot like Billy Napier's, so I am a bit hesitant to pick him as the next head coach.
Exactly. Not ANOTHER "GIANT PREMATURE JUMP UP IN CLASS"!
But though there are a LOT of names on this list, it still brings little in the way of "throw the rest out!" confidence...The best of them seem as unattainable as they do unavailable.
Some ridiculous, some unthinkable, some from the "distant past", others at best from the "distant FUTURE" (if EVER).
But this is what will happen when you fail to face (or to be more precise, FAIL to handle) this sort of crisis of confidence...Fail to handle it AGAIN. And again. And again. FOUR TIMES they have managed to pass the buck on to the NEXT group of incoming freshmen classes.
ENOUGH!
HOWEVER, at THIS point I feel I must say something about anger, frustration and "personal feelings". In each case I have wished each of these guys well, have trusted, supported them and taken them at their word. In some cases that has left me ultimately feeling a sense of BETRAYAL in the way that some have BROKEN that trust. But let us speak the truth: the greatest, and most consistent "failure and betrayal" has been from Stickland and the Board who has backed and enabled him through it all.
Though I have lost confidence and gained little but growing disappointment in the results that have manifested on the field under Billy, I still like and respect him as a man: I believe he has failed to measure up as a Head Coach at what is the acknowledged highest level of competition in college football here in the SEC, that doesn't make him evil.
If we for any reason cannot currently put together the right combination of required components of a deal to bring the IDEAL CANDIDATE to UF at this awkward point mid-season, I'll understand NOT simply bringing in an "interim Coach" just for "show". Billy's done nothing actionable, nothing "wrong" except maybe coach poorly--and LOSE.
So if we are to "limp along for a while" under Napier while the deal for the mythical "guy we're REALLY after" can eventually materialize, well we won't truly KNOW about all that until it actually happens, and at this point, having already had our worst fears for 2024 more or less having come to pass already, I can suffer through the ensuing mediocrity with a certain resigned (even hopeful) patience, I think.
But there damn well better be a PAY OFF!
 

DRU2012

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
(PS And by the way: If the bleeding were to happen to ease, maybe we end up holding ONTO DJ and a few of the other outstanding playmakers Billy has gathered here, no matter what...)
 

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
(PS And by the way: If the bleeding were to happen to ease, maybe we end up holding ONTO DJ and a few of the other outstanding playmakers Billy has gathered here, no matter what...)

The only way for Florida to keep the good parts of its 2024 and projected 2025-2026 talent is to hire a general manager immediately! A general manager would operate the Gator football team like an NFL team and work with agents to keep players irrespective of the coaching changes.
 

DRU2012

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
The only way for Florida to keep the good parts of its 2024 and projected 2025-2026 talent is to hire a general manager immediately! A general manager would operate the Gator football team like an NFL team and work with agents to keep players irrespective of the coaching changes.
Agreed...What are these guys thinking??!
Or maybe the better question is, "Is there a 'counter-force group'--a few backroom power brokers with the money and long time connections to step up and elbow their way back INTO this 'poker game'? IF such exists they MUST step in NOW--Move Stickland OUT and bring in an AD who can believably function in just that "General Managerial" role!
But as things stand and continue to appear to be headed now, regardless of whatever outcome "the Billy discussion" produces, nothing SHORT of something like such a dramatically "preemptive hire" can HOPE to save a significant portion of these recruits--and in so doing give the NEXT Coach some kind of "running start" as his feet hit the ground here.
 

Escambia94

Aerospace Cubicle Engineer (ACE)
Moderator
Agreed...What are these guys thinking??!
Or maybe the better question is, "Is there a 'counter-force group'--a few backroom power brokers with the money and long time connections to step up and elbow their way back INTO this 'poker game'? IF such exists they MUST step in NOW--Move Stickland OUT and bring in an AD who can believably function in just that "General Managerial" role!
But as things stand and continue to appear to be headed now, regardless of whatever outcome "the Billy discussion" produces, nothing SHORT of something like such a dramatically "preemptive hire" can HOPE to save a significant portion of these recruits--and in so doing give the NEXT Coach some kind of "running start" as his feet hit the ground here.
Read my last post on this thread: https://www.gatorenvy.com/threads/t...ball-team-is-not-winning-championships.21268/

This could also apply to your thread “Clear them all out”. The problem with the “fire everyone” approach is that NCAA only allows movement of players within 30 days of a head coach being fired and teams are limited to 10 coaches at a time. However, there are no rules on general managers and when they can be hired. Also, Scott Stricklin has not done enough wrong to warrant being fired in the middle of the season. He is still considered one of the top 3-5 ADs in the country. Some teams like Alabama and Tennessee have a football GM who is quasi independent from the athletic director. The solution is to hire a GM immediately, then fire Billy Napier, name an interim head coach, and have the GM evaluate the interim head coach and Napier’s staff for continuity with the next head coach, along with the best recruits.
 

DRU2012

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Read my last post on this thread: https://www.gatorenvy.com/threads/t...ball-team-is-not-winning-championships.21268/

This could also apply to your thread “Clear them all out”. The problem with the “fire everyone” approach is that NCAA only allows movement of players within 30 days of a head coach being fired and teams are limited to 10 coaches at a time. However, there are no rules on general managers and when they can be hired. Also, Scott Stricklin has not done enough wrong to warrant being fired in the middle of the season. He is still considered one of the top 3-5 ADs in the country. Some teams like Alabama and Tennessee have a football GM who is quasi independent from the athletic director. The solution is to hire a GM immediately, then fire Billy Napier, name an interim head coach, and have the GM evaluate the interim head coach and Napier’s staff for continuity with the next head coach, along with the best recruits.
This is a really informative post: Truth is. I was not AWARE of this distinction, and it DOES affect my views. Dramatically so. I would go so far as to say that in light of it, I would have to shift my emphasis to making just the sort of changes you recommend. It simply make functional/MECHANICAL sense!
(I will now take a look at the recommended link)
 

DRU2012

Super Moderator
Staff member
Super Moderator
Oh--This is one I had already read and (ironically) agreed with; I had simply come to change my mind regarding Stickland...
In my own defense, my feelings regarding Strickland were (in addition to my heightened anger and frustration at the time) based mainly on his personal influence and control in overseeing THE PAST FOUR FAILED HIRES at UF football Coach.
However, based on the specific technicalities and limitations clearly outlined by E--, I have now modified those views to reflect the practical realities of NCAA rules, contractual minutia and "the way things REALLY work".
So be it. We do whatever we NEED to do to get better in a real and practical way.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
20,384
Messages
90,816
Members
1,227
Latest member
Jamesmyday
Top