Whew!I know this thread was meandered about in topics, but for me this thread is about two things: Kyle Trask, and overall QB development at Florida.
Barring anything crazy he will finish with the #1 passer rating in Gator history (2020) and the #9 rating (2019)--counting starters or QBs who took more than half the snaps. Jesse Palmer actually outgunned Doug Johnson, but Johnson took more snaps and is considered the starter. Reminder that Trask was rated as a 2-star by some services and a 3-star by others for a composite rating of 3 stars. No evaluation system by Rivals or 247 or Yahoo would ever look at Trask and rank him higher than that, even knowing what they know today. Trask has the size, but he lacks athleticism and strength to be ranked higher. Dan Mullen even evaluated him slightly lower than Feleipe Franks. This is not a knock against either one of them. Look at their overall rankings below and see that they are very close in performance. Although Franks' performance was cut short by injury in 2019 and is not statistically significant, his performance showed that he was on track to improve significantly over his previous year with Mullen. Both Franks and Jones spent a lot of time in QB camps in the 2018-2019 offseason, and it seemed to help Franks. Trask spent a lot of time in the 2019-2020 offseason in QB camps (alongside Dariq King), and both of them have improved significantly.
Also look at the QBs recruited by Will Muschamp and Jim McDeathThreats: Jeff Driskel (4/5 star), Will Grier (4/5 star), and Jacoby Brissett (4 star). Driskel and Grier performed better after leaving Florida, because they better coaching to help them achieve their performance ceiling and possibly raise that ceiling (Skip Holtz for Driskel, Dana Holgerson for Grier, Matt Canada for Brissett). What this shows us is that the evaluation system used by Rivals and 247 is different from the ones used by coaches, because the recruiting services have to rank raw skills agnostic of a particular system. Urban Meyer is just as good a talent evaluator as Nick Saban, but he is a horrible evaluator of personality and fit for his team. Dan Mullen is an excellent evaluator of personality and fit for his team. Mullen also has a penchant for evaluating upside, which he had to do as the head coach at Mississippi State. Let us focus on Dak Prescott. He was rated a 2 star by some services, and 3 stars by others, for a composite ranking of 3 stars. Dak was recruited by LSU and Louisiana Tech for the class of 2011. Why did LSU pass on Dak? In 2011 LSU took 4-star QB Zach Mettenberger, 4-star QB Jerrard Randall (recruited originally by Billy Gonzalez before he rejoined Dan Mullen's staff; Randall later transferred to Arizona under Rich Rodriguez), and 3-star QB Stephen Rivers (later transferred to Vanderbilt). Reminder that Urban Meyer basically recruited by matching his evaluations against the recruiting services, because he could. Where Meyer failed compared to Saban was in evaluating personality and fit. Saban's recruits know their place as soon as they set foot on campus. Meyer's recruits have historically run rampant on campus since 2006. Mullen's recruits for some reason seem to join a family. There is no talent evaluation service on the planet that measures personality and fit, and that his one of Mullen's strengths that sets him apart from Meyer and maybe Saban.
FLORIDA 2020 Kyle Trask GRSR 148/211 70.10% 2171 YDS 28 TD 3 INT 197.50 RAT
FLORIDA 1995 Danny Wuerffel JR 210/325 64.60% 3266 YDS 35 TD 10 INT 178.40 RAT
WEST VIRGINIA 2018 Will Grier RSR 266/397 67.00% 3864 YDS 37 TD 8 INT 175.50 RAT
FLORIDA 1998 Jesse Palmer SO 73/123 59.30% 1246 YDS 14 TD 5 INT 173.90 RAT
FLORIDA 2001 Brock Berlin SO 36/60 59.90% 483 YDS 9 TD 1 INT 173.80 RAT
FLORIDA 2019 Feleipe Franks RJR 54/71 76.10% 698 YDS 5 TD 3 INT 173.40 RAT
FLORIDA 2007 Tim Tebow SO 234/350 66.90% 3286 YDS 32 TD 6 INT 172.50 RAT
FLORIDA 2008 Tim Tebow JR 192/298 64.40% 2746 YDS 30 TD 4 INT 172.40 RAT
FLORIDA 2001 Rex Grossman SO 259/395 65.60% 3896 YDS 34 TD 12 INT 170.80 RAT
FLORIDA 1996 Danny Wuerffel SR 207/360 57.50% 3625 YDS 39 TD 13 INT 170.60 RAT
FLORIDA 2009 Tim Tebow SR 213/314 67.80% 2895 YDS 21 TD 5 INT 164.20 RAT
WEST VIRGINIA 2017 Will Grier RJR 250/388 64.40% 3490 YDS 34 TD 12 INT 162.70 RAT
FLORIDA 2000 Rex Grossman FR 131/212 61.80% 1866 YDS 21 TD 7 INT 161.80 RAT
ARKANSAS 2020 Feleipe Franks GRSR 138/202 68.30% 1678 YDS 16 TD 3 INT 161.30 RAT
FLORIDA 2019 Kyle Trask RJR 237/354 66.90% 2941 YDS 25 TD 7 INT 156.20 RAT
FLORIDA 1994 Danny Wuerffel SO 132/212 62.30% 1754 YDS 18 TD 9 INT 151.30 RAT
FLORIDA 2014 Treon Harris FR 55/111 49.50% 1019 YDS 9 TD 4 INT 146.20 RAT
FLORIDA 1993 Danny Wuerffel FR 159/273 58.20% 2230 YDS 22 TD 10 INT 146.10 RAT
FLORIDA 2015 Will Grier FR 105/160 65.60% 1202 YDS 10 TD 3 INT 145.60 RAT
FLORIDA 1998 Doug Johnson JR 154/274 56.20% 2346 YDS 19 TD 8 INT 145.20 RAT
FLORIDA 2004 Chris Leak SO 238/399 59.60% 3197 YDS 29 TD 12 INT 144.90 RAT
FLORIDA 2006 Chris Leak SR 232/365 63.60% 2942 YDS 23 TD 13 INT 144.90 RAT
FLORIDA 2018 Feleipe Franks RSO 175/299 58.50% 2284 YDS 23 TD 6 INT 144.10 RAT
FLORIDA 2011 John Brantley SR 144/240 60.00% 2044 YDS 11 TD 7 INT 140.80 RAT
MIAMI (FL) 2004 Brock Berlin SR 195/348 56.00% 2680 YDS 22 TD 6 INT 138.10 RAT
NC STATE 2013 Jacoby Brissett JR 221/370 59.70% 2606 YDS 23 TD 5 INT 136.70 RAT
FLORIDA 2005 Chris Leak JR 235/374 62.80% 2639 YDS 20 TD 6 INT 136.50 RAT
FLORIDA 2013 Jeff Driskel JR 42/61 68.90% 477 YDS 2 TD 3 INT 135.50 RAT
FLORIDA 1997 Doug Johnson SO 148/269 55.00% 2023 YDS 21 TD 12 INT 135.00 RAT
FLORIDA 2012 Jacoby Brissett SO 23/35 65.70% 249 YDS 1 TD 0 INT 134.90 RAT
FLORIDA 2003 Chris Leak FR 190/320 59.40% 2435 YDS 16 TD 11 INT 132.90 RAT
FLORIDA 1999 Doug Johnson SR 190/337 56.40% 2574 YDS 20 TD 13 INT 132.40 RAT
FLORIDA 2012 Jeff Driskel SO 156/245 63.70% 1646 YDS 12 TD 5 INT 132.20 RAT
NC STATE 2014 Jacoby Brissett SR 237/395 60.00% 2662 YDS 20 TD 6 INT 130.30 RAT
FLORIDA 2016 Austin Appleby TR-SR 127/209 60.80% 1447 YDS 10 TD 7 INT 128.00 RAT
FLORIDA 2000 Jesse Palmer SR 116/223 52.00% 1653 YDS 11 TD 4 INT 127.00 RAT
FLORIDA 2002 Rex Grossman JR 287/503 57.10% 3402 YDS 22 TD 17 INT 121.50 RAT
MIAMI (FL) 2003 Brock Berlin JR 211/352 59.90% 2419 YDS 12 TD 17 INT 119.30 RAT
FLORIDA 2016 Luke Del Rio TR-SO 114/201 56.70% 1358 YDS 8 TD 8 INT 118.60 RAT
FLORIDA 2015 Treon Harris SO 119/235 50.60% 1676 YDS 9 TD 6 INT 118.10 RAT
FLORIDA 2010 John Brantley JR 200/329 60.80% 2061 YDS 9 TD 10 INT 116.40 RAT
FLORIDA 2017 Luke Del Rio TR-JR 16/25 64.00% 138 YDS 1 TD 1 INT 115.60 RAT
FLORIDA 2017 Feleipe Franks RFR 125/229 54.60% 1438 YDS 9 TD 8 INT 113.30 RAT
FLORIDA 2014 Jeff Driskel JR 114/212 53.80% 1140 YDS 9 TD 10 INT 103.50 RAT
A lot of deep analysis there, even for YOU, E-.
I think you are on to something, though, particularly in your concluding points regarding what may well set Mullens APART from the rest—even Saban, whom (as I have tried to stress in my OWN somewhat “scrambled” way) is not so much “BETTER” at what he is trying to achieve as completely DIFFERENT in attitude, approach, and ultimate “general aims”: In this way, my perhaps somewhat clumsy, to some perhaps dubious parallels to Jedi mythology I think DO present some tangible advantages in approaching and understanding the wholesale differences between them—in method, aims and ultimate results.
But I’ve beat the HELL out of THAT one, I grant you, and will henceforth cease and disgust!
No, it is sufficient to simply say that they are two COMPLETELY DIFFERENT men and METHODS—and now, as Mullens’ Gators come into their own, begin to approach the level of talent, competence and success that Saban’s Alabama programs have enjoyed for a decade, only THIS season finally seeming on the verge of confronting each other on something approaching “equal terms” on the gridiron, we can begin to fairly judge and compare them there.
I THINK (and HOPE) that we will be able to extend that process for an extended period of time!