I am okay with Trask not winning the Heisman. I am a Gator, but when I take off the orange and blue glasses what I see is that Trask had a horrible game against an over-matched LSU team. That loss was inexcusable, although it was not necessarily Trask's fault. At the end of the day, being responsible for 3 turnovers in a game where you were favored by 2 scores is a good way to lose the Heisman.
It would still be possible to argue for Trask to win the Heisman based on a lot of other factors, but the odds certainly are against him. He did not lose the Heisman against Alabama, considering the fact that Alabama only had to defend the pass and still were not able to stop the Trask train. Some are also going to point out that Trask has a much cleaner record than Mac Jones, who has a DUI arrest under his belt in an incident where he forged a driver's license and wrecked the car. I am not a fan of "cancel culture", but if the Heisman committee is going to split hairs over performance on the field as a way to narrow the field, they should consider performance off the field as another means to narrow the field.
Still, the title of this thread was "keep it simple, stupid", and the simple fact is that Trask turned the ball over 3 times against LSU. The Heisman trophy is a very subjective one wrought with sports politics. Trask could still win a Maxwell Award or Davey O'Brien and I would be fine with that.
I guess I can’t help but agree with you up to a certain point about Trask, his game against LSU, and its potential effect on his Heisman candidacy—IF that WERE one (supposedly “important”) reason given for NOT giving it to him...but it WASN’T the reason we lost, per se—MUCH more a function of a poor Grantham defense having ITS worst game, not to mention lackadaisical effort and outright mistakes all over the field all evening (culminating in the notorious “Thrown Cleat Incident” seeming to “throw away our shot at last-moment redemption”)—THEN Kyle somehow driving the field with seconds left in the game to leave the normally “MONEY Mac “ with the normally makeable fg to take it to overtime after all.
Of course, on this night he MISSES where the opponent kicker who’d NOT been known for either consistency OR distance had kicked HIS 50-plusser to PUT us in that hole to begin with...
No, Kyle had already more or less “redeemed” HIS “off night” with his carry-the-team-on-an-off-night play; had MacPhearson converted HIS clutch kick who’s to say we don’t eventually WIN that game and then we’re at least TALKING about all this differently—the Heisman AND the Playoffs!
No...I stand by my original point above here:
I AM SICK TO DEATH OF THE TALK AND THE WHOLE PATH OF DECISIONS AND RATIONALES THAT GOT US HERE.
I believe that Major College Football is BROKEN. I don’t know for sure whether that is a function of the circumstances thrust upon us by Covid, its compromises and its effects—or whether it is itself a symptom of DEEPER complications that, though setting in now, were set in motion by the details and timing of the shift to the 4-team playoff in the first place, and became eventually inevitable all the sooner with Covid’s onslaught.
As for what to DO about it...
I’m not so sure the seeming “obvious”, a FURTHER expansion of that system to include more and more teams, would be any kind of improvement—in fact, it MIGHT well be the further sealing of our fate, the continued descent of our overall system.
The uncertain, the unknown, argument and continued debate, a certain amount of CHAOS was not and IS not necessarily the enemy of competition and interest.
All of that to a certain extent will be with us regardless—to that same extent perhaps we are best off EMBRACING IT!
That there may be “clusters of elite programs” that tend to compete together for a time then one by one, to varying degrees fade for a time and need rejeuvenation, regrowth and redevelopment, is a FACT of life in our sport. This isn’t College Basketball where you get one freakishly talented big guy who comes to your school, and/or a freakishly-intelligent Coach-with-a-plan can in short order turn a program around...
No matter WHAT, it takes some time to build, Coach and EVOLVE into a “WINNER”. Players on the field and in depth, talented and knowledgeable coaches on the sidelines... It’s just the way the whole thing is put together in the FIRST place!
And its a big part of what it takes, and how we all come to take it so CLOSE TO HEART OVER TIME.
We can talk about possible ways to introduce “circulation”, upwards or downwards, to the “system” (for example, introduce something like what they have in English Football (“League” soccer), with “ Divisions (I, II, III and more?), where the highest of “II” and onward down moves UP a Division at the end of each season, bumping OUT the lowest of the Division above...
But I would be VERY CAREFUL about even something like that...We had operated for many years with an imperfect yet functional system that depended SOLELY on arguing individuals and competing “governing bodies”, public argument and opinion to ultimately find our way to an imperfect “Public Media Champion”... This was improved somewhat I think by our first efforts at formalizing that process, into the BCS and beyond...Personally, I am not ready to FURTHER EXPAND based merely on what has ensued THIS season after Covid and the various Conferences scrambling separately in search of their own rules, spurred mainly (and so imperfectly) by self-INTEREST it seems clear and the decisions made so unevenly (and yes, unfairly) at the end here in terms of “number of games played” and the like (and not even sticking to THOSE, as it suited them later) only further clouds these issues.
No, it seems best to at most “stand pat” for now; return to what is and has been the “status quo” for the short time we have had it in place—see if it works, and if so, how satisfied we all are with it, in the coming season or two...and if we are to further “tweak it”, we do so “in small steps”, CAREFULLY: I am NOT in favor of some knee jerk “OPENING UP”, some sudden further EXPANSION of the “CFB Playoffs”—certainly not just on the evidence of the mess a few biased, selfish and desperate men have begotten, after all: Men, by the way, who are NOT from OUR conference, who in fact fear and resent our power and superior programs top-to-bottom when compared to both their leagues AND their own mismanagement!
Let us NOT take advice or example from people who certainly do not themselves have OUR “best interests” at heart.