Pat White #1?

[preachinGator]

CAN YOU BELIEVE PAT WHITE IS THE #1 QB IN THE NATION ACCORDING TO SPORTINGNEWS.COM?
How ridiculous can this be?

http://www.sportingnews.com/yourturn/viewtopic.php?t=418949

Quarterback

1. Pat White, West Virginia
2. Tim Tebow, Florida
3. Chase Daniel, Missouri
4. Sam Bradford, Oklahoma
5. Matt Stafford, Georgia
6. Todd Reesing, Kansas
7. Graham Harrell, Texas Tech
8. Cullen Harper, Clemson
9. Kellen Lewis, Indiana
10. Willie Tuitama, Arizona

 

[shandsgator8]

I'm not that surprised. Without Tebow, we'd still be SEC title contenders and even in the national title picture (barely). Without White, WVU is nothing.

 

[Warf_GatorFanForLife]

i am surprised that matt stafford is not higher on the list myself im a huge tim tebow fan Id do anything to met the guy but wow Stafford should be higher

 

[gatorlover97]

Tebow should be #1 and it shouldn't even be close.

 

[leakbrewergator]

I don't see how a returning Heisman winning QB isn't the #1 rated QB...

 

[zoom there goes percy]

Especially since he is a returning JUNIOR

 

[Leakfan12]

Why is White number one? Tebow is the better passer. Nothing against White but he's more of a runner.

 

[Win It 4 The Zooker]

Why is White number one? Tebow is the better passer. Nothing against White but he's more of a runner.

Honestly, I dont really see either Quarterback as a classic passer. While Tebow won the Heisman, Pat White led his team to a better overall season. And don't even say it's because W. Virginia was more talented than Florida. The Gators have so many more weapons than the Mountaineers yet they won the Fiesta Bowl handidly while we couldn't win the Capitol One Bowl. I'm not dissing Tim or even suggesting that this was his fault, I'm just saying that I can see how someone could justify ranking Pat White higher than him.

 

[Swampman]

I'm not that surprised. Without Tebow, we'd still be SEC title contenders and even in the national title picture (barely). Without White, WVU is nothing.

The Gators would not be SEC Title contenders with Cam Newton leading us. If Tebow goes down, we'll still be OK... but no way could we win the SEC.

Here's my top 10:

Quarterback

1. Tim Tebow, Florida
2. Matt Stafford, Georgia
3. Pat White, West Virginia
4. Sam Bradford, Oklahoma
5. Chase Daniel, Missouri
6. Graham Harrell, Texas Tech
7. Todd Reesing, Kansas
8. Cullen Harper, Clemson
9. Kellen Lewis, Indiana
10. Willie Tuitama, Arizona

 

[shandsgator8]

I didn't say we'd win the SEC with Brantley or Newton, but we'd still have a shot and would be mentioned in the same sentence as UGA, Auburn, and LSU regarding SEC title talk.

While I haven't said our defense will be "much improved" (I need to see a few games first), it's possible we can have a very good defense this season. Assuming this is the case and Moody/Rainey do well running the ball I see no reason why we couldn't win the SEC, even without Tebow.

 

[preachinGator]

I didn't say we'd win the SEC with Brantley or Newton, but we'd still have a shot and would be mentioned in the same sentence as UGA, Auburn, and LSU regarding SEC title talk.

While I haven't said our defense will be "much improved" (I need to see a few games first), it's possible we can have a very good defense this season. Assuming this is the case and Moody/Rainey do well running the ball I see no reason why we couldn't win the SEC, even without Tebow.

I totally agree. Tebow may be the best there is right now. But Newton is good too. And with a good team....a mediocre QB can win teams. look at Miami when they had Ken Dorsey. He only did as good as he did because the front line wouldn't let anyone touch him.

 

[GatorGuy8]

I'm not that surprised. Without Tebow, we'd still be SEC title contenders and even in the national title picture (barely). Without White, WVU is nothing.

Bull crap. You're buying into that, huh? Without Tebow last year we don't win 6 games.

 

[shandsgator8]

Bull crap. You're buying into that, huh? Without Tebow last year we don't win 6 games.

Last year isn't this year.:no: Last year, our defense wasn't as experienced and we didn't have Moody, Rainey, etc.

Trying comparing Meyer's 1st and 2nd seasons at Florida - we had a vast improvement his second season, especially in our defense. No reason to think the same thing won't happen, although the extent of the improvement is up to debate.

 

[GatorGuy8]

Last year isn't this year.:no: Last year, our defense wasn't as experienced and we didn't have Moody, Rainey, etc.

Trying comparing Meyer's 1st and 2nd seasons at Florida - we had a vast improvement his second season, especially in our defense. No reason to think the same thing won't happen, although the extent of the improvement is up to debate.

I never claimed last year was this year. But there is no way in hell that Pat White should be rated above Tebow. A blind man could see that.

 

[Leakfan12]

Well to be fair Dorsey was a good quarterback (the last good UM QB).

 

[O-town Gator]

I totally agree. Tebow may be the best there is right now. But Newton is good too. And with a good team....a mediocre QB can win teams. look at Miami when they had Ken Dorsey. He only did as good as he did because the front line wouldn't let anyone touch him.

You hit the nail on the head right there. If Dorsey was THAT good, he would have been drafted higher than the middle of the 7th round. It was the offense around him that made him look good.

Tim Tebow is the #1 QB in college football right now; in spite of Cam Newton having had a poor O&B game this year he has some strong skills and will improve with added playing time. With the limited time he had in 2007, he showed a glimpse of what he's capable of out there. The two-QB system has worked at UF in the past (Johnson-Brindise and Leak-Tebow), and it's possible that we could have the best QB tandem with Tebow-Newton if all goes well this fall.

As far as Pat White goes, let's see how he adapts to Stewart's new offense at WVU and works with it. Some QB's adapt well to coaching changes, and some do not.

 

[shandsgator8]

I never claimed last year was this year. But there is no way in hell that Pat White should be rated above Tebow. A blind man could see that.

I didn't say White was better than Tebow, I said he's probably more important to his team than Tebow is to Florida. Like I said before, WVU without White basically has no chance at winning the Big East undefeated (or win the Big East, period), but Florida without Tebow can still have a shot at the SEC and if our defense and conventional running game were to significantly improve, we could still have a shot at a national title game.

Given the above, why would you talk about last season? Who cares about what Florida would have done last season without Tebow.

 

[nismodrift]

Honestly, I dont really see either Quarterback as a classic passer. While Tebow won the Heisman, Pat White led his team to a better overall season. And don't even say it's because W. Virginia was more talented than Florida. The Gators have so many more weapons than the Mountaineers yet they won the Fiesta Bowl handidly while we couldn't win the Capitol One Bowl. I'm not dissing Tim or even suggesting that this was his fault, I'm just saying that I can see how someone could justify ranking Pat White higher than him.

Ok wait a minute, I'm pretty sure WVU actually had defense, unlike the gators, with good defense you can have a decent QB, with horrible defense we had an amazing QB and still didn't do naything, I still say Tebow is better than Pat White and without Tebow and Harvins there's no way we could of outscored what the opponents got off our defense.